What I've Come to Believe About Difficult Decisions
For much of my professional life, I've worked in finance, investing, and business, where making decisions under uncertainty is part of the job. I've spent decades evaluating risks, weighing competing interests, considering alternative outcomes, and trying to determine the best course of action when information is incomplete and the consequences matter.
Many of the disciplines involved in making good investment decisions are equally valuable when navigating difficult human situations. Whether the issue involves a business partnership, a family disagreement, a leadership challenge, or a deeply personal decision, the underlying questions are often surprisingly similar. What do we know? What are we assuming? What are the alternatives? What are the risks and consequences of each? And what are we actually trying to achieve?
I've sometimes described this as bringing an investor's lens to human situations. The math doesn't change, but the inputs to the model do. By "the math," I don't necessarily mean numbers or equations. I mean the discipline of taking a complicated situation, identifying the variables that matter, examining how they interact, testing our assumptions, and evaluating the choices available to us.
One lesson from my years in investing is that some of the most important variables in any consequential decision are precisely those that are hardest to measure. Trust, loyalty, resentment, dignity, relationships, and peace of mind may not fit neatly into a spreadsheet, but they can matter more to the outcome than the things we can readily quantify. Their inability to be measured doesn't make them any less consequential.
I remember investment opportunities that appeared extraordinarily attractive on a conventional risk-return basis. The securities were cheap, and the expected returns more than compensated for the apparent financial risks. But even a financially attractive investment could carry consequences that weren't captured by the usual measures of risk and return.
Our investment committee recommendations routinely included a section called "C-1 Risk." The question was simple: How would this look if it appeared on page C-1 of The Wall Street Journal? We were asking ourselves what an extreme downside outcome might mean not only for the portfolio, but for the fund, our business, and each of us individually. Even a remote possibility of loss could carry consequences for client trust and our reputations that far exceeded the financial damage. Those risks were difficult to quantify, but they were real, and they belonged in the decision. The math hadn't changed. We were simply making sure the model included the things that mattered.
And then there's emotion. Emotions aren't simply another set of variables to consider. They can influence the way we perceive and evaluate every other variable. Fear can make risks appear larger than they are. Anger can lead us to interpret another person's actions in the worst possible light. Pride can make compromise feel like defeat. Attachment can cause us to overlook evidence that contradicts what we want to believe. Under pressure, these influences can become particularly powerful, often without our recognizing that they're affecting our judgment. As I explored in an earlier article, Judgment Under Pressure, urgency and clarity are not the same thing, although it's remarkably easy to mistake one for the other.
This doesn't mean emotions are bad or should be ignored. Quite the opposite. Our feelings often tell us something important about what we value, what we fear losing, and what we're trying to protect. The challenge is learning to distinguish between what we feel, what we believe, and what we actually know.
We all have blind spots. No matter how intelligent, experienced, or thoughtful we may be, we see the world through the lens of our own experiences, beliefs, interests, and emotions. Because that perspective feels so natural to us, we may not recognize that it's only one way of seeing the situation. We construct narratives that make sense of what we're experiencing, and then begin interpreting new information through those narratives. The more personally invested we become, the harder it can be to question the stories we've told ourselves.
This is where another set of eyes can be invaluable. Someone who isn't emotionally invested in the outcome can sometimes recognize assumptions we're making, questions we're not asking, or possibilities we haven't considered. Not because they're necessarily smarter or more experienced, but because they're looking at the situation from a different vantage point.
In investing, it's common practice to challenge the assumptions underlying an investment thesis before committing capital. The same discipline can be valuable when we're about to commit ourselves to a consequential course of action in our personal or professional lives. Sometimes a different question, or the recognition that something we've assumed to be true may not be true at all, can change the way we understand the entire problem.
Importantly, this isn't about having someone tell us what to do. The decisions, and their consequences, remain ours. It's about having someone help us think through the situation, challenge our assumptions, and consider alternatives without the emotional baggage that can make it difficult to do those things ourselves.
Of course, seeing a situation more clearly doesn't guarantee that we'll make the right decision, much less achieve the outcome we hope for. One of the lessons investing teaches us is that the quality of a decision and the quality of its outcome aren't necessarily the same thing. Good decisions can produce disappointing results, and poor decisions can sometimes work out remarkably well. Uncertainty, timing, and plain old luck will always play a role.
But while we can't control every outcome, we can exercise greater control over the process by which we make decisions. We can question our assumptions, challenge our interpretations, consider alternatives, and think more carefully about the consequences of our choices. We can also recognize that the best available option may not be perfect, and that sometimes the costs of continuing a conflict exceed whatever we might gain by prevailing.
Clarity creates options. When we begin to see a situation differently, possibilities that once seemed unavailable may emerge. Sometimes that means finding a compromise, having a different conversation, changing course, or recognizing that a relationship or arrangement has run its course. Sometimes it means deciding that the best thing to do is nothing at all. What matters is that we're making a considered choice rather than simply reacting to circumstances.
After decades of evaluating investments, navigating business challenges, and helping people think through difficult situations, I find myself returning to a surprisingly simple idea: the quality of our decisions depends on the quality of our thinking. We can't eliminate uncertainty, control other people, or guarantee outcomes. But we can become more thoughtful about how we see our circumstances, what we assume to be true, and which consequences really matter.
That's what I've come to believe about difficult decisions. And, in many ways, it's why I created Resolve.
Andrew Akers is the Founder of Resolve Advisory, where he advises business owners, executives, investors, and families through high-stakes situations involving conflict, uncertainty, and important decisions. Learn more at www.resolve-advisory.com.